Restoring Historic Buildings: Tips for Matching Old Bricks

The Science of Brick Strength: What Builders Need to KnowBricks have been a cornerstone of construction for millennia, combining durability, thermal mass, and aesthetic appeal. However, not all bricks are created equal. Understanding the science behind brick strength helps builders select the right product for structural demands, design longevity, and safety. This article explains what determines brick strength, how it’s measured, what affects it in service, and practical guidance for builders.


What “Strength” Means for Bricks

In masonry, “strength” refers to a brick’s ability to resist loads and environmental stresses without cracking, deforming, or failing. Key aspects include:

  • Compressive strength — resistance to crushing under load; the primary structural property for bricks.
  • Flexural (bending) strength — resistance to bending forces; relevant for bricks used in lintels, arches, or pavements.
  • Shear strength — resistance to sliding forces across a plane; important where lateral loads or masonry connections occur.
  • Tensile strength — bricks are weak in tension; tensile resistance is often provided by reinforcement or mortar bonding.
  • Durability — resistance to weathering, freeze–thaw cycles, salt attack, and chemical exposure; a strong brick may still fail over time if not durable.

What Determines Compressive Strength

Several factors at manufacture and material level control a brick’s compressive strength:

  • Clay composition and impurities: The mineralogy of the clay (kaolinite, illite, montmorillonite) and presence of silica, iron oxides, or organic matter affect sintering behavior and final microstructure.
  • Firing temperature and time: Higher firing temperatures (within manufacturer-specified limits) usually increase vitrification, reducing porosity and raising strength—until overfiring causes distortions or brittleness.
  • Particle size and compaction: Well-graded clay with proper particle packing and controlled forming pressure produces denser green bricks and higher final strength.
  • Additives and tempering: Sand, grog (crushed brick), or other tempering materials control shrinkage, reduce cracking, and influence porosity and strength.
  • Manufacturing method: Extruded, pressed, or hand-molded bricks have different densities and strength distributions; machine-pressed bricks typically show greater uniformity and higher strength.
  • Porosity and pore structure: Lower total porosity and finer, closed porosity generally increase compressive strength; however, connectivity of pores affects water ingress and durability.

Typical ranges: Common building bricks often have compressive strengths from about 5 MPa to over 50 MPa depending on type (e.g., soft mud vs. high-quality engineering bricks).


Standard Tests and Specifications

Bricks are tested and classified by standards that specify test methods and minimum strengths. Important tests include:

  • Compressive strength test: Single-brick or bed-of-mortar tests per standards such as ASTM C67, BS EN 772-1, or local codes.
  • Water absorption: Indicates porosity and potential for frost damage; often correlated with durability.
  • Efflorescence and salt testing: Determines susceptibility to soluble salts that cause surface deposits or sub-surface damage.
  • Freeze–thaw resistance: Relevant in cold climates; standards prescribe cycles to simulate weathering.
  • Dimensions and tolerances: Ensures consistent load distribution and mortar joint behavior.

Builders should refer to local codes and manufacturer data sheets; many regions classify bricks into categories (e.g., ASTM specifies grades based on compressive strength and absorption).


How Mortar, Bonding, and Construction Affect Strength

A brick wall’s performance depends as much on workmanship and mortar as on individual brick strength:

  • Mortar strength and type: Mortar should complement brick strength. Using excessively strong mortar (very high cement content) can concentrate stress and cause brittle failure in weaker bricks. Conversely, too-weak mortar reduces load distribution and bond.
  • Bed-joint thickness and consistency: Uniform, properly filled joints distribute loads evenly and help avoid point stresses.
  • Bond pattern: Running bond, English bond, Flemish bond, and other patterns affect wall stability, load transfer, and shear resistance.
  • Curing and moisture control: Proper curing of mortar and controlled moisture during construction prevent early failures and help achieve design strengths.
  • Reinforcement and ties: Steel reinforcement, wall ties, and lintels add tensile and flexural capacity where needed.

Practical rule: For typical load-bearing masonry, match mortar class to brick strength per codes (for example, use Type N or S mortars with certain common bricks) rather than always choosing the strongest cement-rich mortar.


Environmental and Long-Term Factors

Even high-strength bricks can deteriorate over time due to environment and use:

  • Freeze–thaw cycles: Water penetration into pores freezes and expands, causing microcracking. Bricks with high absorption and connected porosity are especially vulnerable.
  • Salt crystallization: Salts carried by moisture can form crystals in pores, exerting pressure that spalls or flakes the surface.
  • Chemical attack: Acidic pollutants, sulfates, or aggressive soils can degrade clay or mortar.
  • Biological growth: Moss or roots in joints can retain moisture and cause physical damage.
  • Thermal cycling: Expansion and contraction over daily/seasonal cycles can create stresses, especially where different materials meet.

Choosing bricks with appropriate water absorption, density, and fired quality for the climate and exposure is crucial.


Practical Selection Guide for Builders

  1. Identify structural requirements:

    • For non-loadbearing partitions, standard facing bricks may suffice.
    • For load-bearing walls, check required compressive strength and select bricks rated above the design load with appropriate safety factors.
  2. Match brick to environment:

    • In freeze–thaw climates pick low-absorption bricks or engineering bricks rated for frost resistance.
    • Near coasts or for salt-exposed sites, choose bricks with low porosity and good salt resistance.
  3. Consider aesthetics vs performance:

    • Facing bricks prioritize appearance; ensure they also meet minimum durability requirements for exposure.
    • Engineering bricks prioritize performance (low porosity, high strength) and are best for below-grade or severe-exposure uses.
  4. Check manufacturer data and standards:

    • Verify compressive strength, water absorption, dimensional tolerances, and any certifications (e.g., ASTM, BS EN).
    • Ask for sample test certificates if project-critical.
  5. Coordinate with mortar and detailing:

    • Specify compatible mortar class and joint thickness.
    • Detail flashing, weep holes, and cavity trays to prevent moisture accumulation.

Common Mistakes and How to Avoid Them

  • Using overly stiff/strong mortar with weak bricks — match mortar to masonry to avoid brittle failures.
  • Ignoring water-management details — install proper flashings, copings, and weeps.
  • Choosing bricks solely on appearance — verify durability for the exposure.
  • Poor curing or rapid drying — control moisture during and after construction, especially in hot, dry, or windy conditions.
  • Skipping quality control — test delivered batches and inspect for cracks, warpage, or inconsistent firing.

Quick Reference: Typical Brick Types and Strengths

Brick type Typical compressive strength (approx.) Typical use
Common clay brick 5–15 MPa Internal/non-critical walls, general construction
Facing brick 10–30 MPa External walls where appearance matters
Engineering brick (Class A/B) 30–100+ MPa High-strength, low-absorption uses; foundations, damp-proof courses
Sand-lime brick 5–40 MPa Precise dimensions, good surface finish, varied structural uses
Concrete brick 10–60 MPa Versatile; can match strength needs, often used where uniformity is required

Case Example: Choosing Bricks for a Cold Coastal Town

Requirements:

  • Two-story load-bearing brick wall
  • Severe freeze–thaw and salt spray exposure
  • Expected service life: 100+ years

Decision steps:

  • Specify engineering or high-quality facing bricks with compressive strength ≥ 40 MPa and low water absorption (< 6–8%).
  • Use a moderate-strength, lime-enhanced mortar to allow some flexibility and breathability.
  • Detail cavity walls with a robust cavity tray, stainless-steel ties, and adequate weeps to prevent moisture trapping.
  • Implement quality control: sample compressive tests, absorption checks, and visual inspection on delivery.

Final Thoughts

Brick strength is a function of materials science, manufacturing, design, and construction practice. Selecting the right brick means balancing compressive strength, porosity, durability, and aesthetics while coordinating mortar, detailing, and site conditions. When in doubt, rely on tested material data and local codes—and involve a structural engineer for critical load-bearing or severe-exposure situations.

Comments

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *